Feeling Overwhelmed by Exercise Choices? Here’s How to Start Strength Training the Right Way

If you're new to strength training, you're not alone in feeling overwhelmed. With endless options like yoga, Pilates, boot camps, HIIT classes, and barbell training - not to mention the constant stream of online advice - it's hard to know where to begin. Everyone seems to have a different opinion about what's "best," what to avoid, and how to train "correctly."

At CAIRN Strength, we help people cut through that noise by focusing on what works. This blog will walk you through how to approach strength training with clarity, confidence, and results - no matter your starting point.

Why Simplicity Beats Complexity in Strength Training

One of the biggest mistakes beginners make is jumping into workouts that are too complicated. Fancy exercises on unstable surfaces or movements that require expert coordination may look impressive, but they often aren't effective for building meaningful strength - especially at the start.

Instead, focus on foundational, compound exercises like:

  • Squats
  • Deadlifts
  • Bench Press
  • Overhead Press

These multi-joint movements activate the most muscle mass and offer the greatest return on investment (ROI) for your time and effort.

Click the titles below to read more:

How to Choose the Right Exercises for You

When designing a strength training program, there are two essential questions:

  1. What is your goal? (Lose fat, gain muscle, build strength, improve health, etc.)
  2. What is your training history? (Are you a beginner, intermediate, or advanced?)

Once you answer those, you can start selecting exercises that match your needs. For example:

  • A beginner might benefit from machine-based leg presses while learning movement patterns.
  • A more experienced trainee may progress to barbell back squats for greater long-term gains.

The key is not to copy someone else's plan, but to play the right "exercise cards" based on your individual context.

What Makes an Exercise Worth Doing?

To evaluate the effectiveness of an exercise, ask:

  • How much muscle mass does it use?
  • How much range of motion is involved?
  • How much weight can I move safely with it?

Exercises like squats and deadlifts check all three boxes. Isolation exercises (like bicep curls) can still be useful, but they're generally less efficient. Think of them as "sprinkles" on top of the main lifts - a way to add volume or target specific muscles, not the foundation of your program.

How Much Should You Work Out Each Week?

You don't need to train every day to make progress. In fact, even one well-structured strength workout per week can lead to results - especially for beginners. More frequent training (2–3 times per week) generally leads to faster improvements, but consistency matters more than frequency at first.

Your schedule might look like this:

  • 1x/week: Minimal progress, but still effective for beginners.
  • 2–3x/week: Ideal for most people looking to build strength or improve body composition.
  • 4+ days/week: Suitable for more advanced trainees with specific goals and recovery strategies.

How Heavy Should You Lift?

If you're just starting out, use moderate weights you can lift with control and good form. You shouldn't be straining on day one.

Over time, you can use tools like RPE (Rating of Perceived Exertion) to gauge effort. For beginners, aim to stop with 3–5 reps left "in the tank." As you become more experienced, you can push closer to failure, especially with lighter, single-joint movements.

For example:

  • Big lifts (like squats or deadlifts): Leave a few reps in reserve to avoid excessive fatigue.
  • Smaller lifts (like curls or triceps): You can train closer to failure safely and more often.

What About Older Adults and Beginners?

Strength training isn't just for athletes or the young - it's for everyone. In fact, older adults and previously inactive individuals can benefit dramatically from even small changes in strength and mobility.

Something as simple as sitting and standing from a chair can be a legitimate strength challenge for some. These "basic" movements have huge carryover into daily life and independence. If that's where you're starting - that's great. That is training.

Final Thoughts: Start Where You Are, Build From There

The truth is, strength training doesn't have to be complicated - and it shouldn't be. You don't need to do every exercise or follow a perfect plan. You just need to start smart, stay consistent, and adjust as you go.

At CAIRN Strength, we help people train with purpose, whether you're brand new to exercise or looking to level up your program. If you're not sure how to begin or need help building a sustainable routine, we're here to guide you.

physical therapy Memphis TN